4 bold moves teams could make ahead of the Trade Deadline
It's never too early for mock trade proposals!
There is an unprecedented amount of parity across Major League Baseball this season. That is especially true in the American League, where the only teams that are more than three games above .500 as of Wednesday, May 13 are the Tampa Bay Rays (28-14) and the New York Yankees (27-17).
Looking at the division races, the Minnesota Twins, Detroit Tigers and Kansas City Royals are tied for last place in the AL Central with 19-24 records, but are all just four games back of the first-place Cleveland Guardians. In the AL West, the Texas Rangers (21-22) are 1 ½ games back and the Seattle Mariners (21-23) are two games back of the first-place Athletics. Every team in the NL Central is above .500.
The Boston Red Sox, who are in last place in the AL East with a 18-24 record, are still just 2 1/2 games back of the third Wild Card spot.
The most significant consequence of this parity–absolute chaos at the trade deadline. Will teams in the American League decide to go all-in even if they are hovering around .500 because of the weaker field? Will one of the disappointing teams with a high payroll, like the Red Sox, New York Mets, Philadelphia Phillies or San Francisco Giants sell?
It is still early, but here are four bold moves that teams could make ahead of the 2026 MLB Trade Deadline on Aug. 3 at 6:00 p.m. ET.
1. New York Yankees receive: OF Mike Trout, Los Angeles Angels receive: LHP Ryan Weathers, OF Spencer Jones (Yankees No. 6 prospect per MLB Pipeline)
With Mike Trout returning to near-MVP form, now makes the most sense for a struggling Los Angeles Angels team to finally cut bait from their superstar and sell high while he is still healthy and performing. Trout has 11 home runs, a .936 OPS, a 160 wRC+ and is playing solid defense in center field. But, in an all-too-familiar situation, the Angels are in last place in a weak AL West with a 16-28 record and are still not able to string together wins even with a healthy Trout.
The Yankees could be a perfect trade partner for Trout. Center field is one of the few positions that New York could look to upgrade, with Trent Grisham hitting under .200 and regressing back to how he performed at the plate the last few seasons. The Angels have struggled to produce young starting pitchers, and with Carlos Rodon back in the rotation and Gerrit Cole on the way, the Yankees suddenly have a surplus of starting arms.
Ryan Weathers has been a revelation for the Yankees since they traded for him from the Miami Marlins this past offseason. Trading him would hurt, but with a wide-open American League and an aging core, the Yankees should be going all-in on this season. Throwing the hulking 6’7” Jones, one of the Yankees’ top prospects, in, should be enough to get Trout to the Bronx and finally give the all-time great a chance to finally compete for a championship.
2. Seattle Mariners receive: SS CJ Abrams, Washington Nationals receive: 2B Cole Young, RHP Ryan Sloan (MLB No. 22, Mariners No. 3 prospect per MLB Pipeline)
With Eli Willits, who was recently named the No. 4 prospect in all of baseball per MLB Pipeline and was the first overall pick in last year’s draft, getting off to a great start to his pro career, the Nationals can afford to move on from CJ Abrams. Abrams is infamously streaky and is a sub-par defender at shortstop, and trading him while he still has team control before he is expected to hit free agency after the 2028 season would allow the Nationals to continue to stock up their minor league system in this stage of their organizational rebuild under new president of baseball operations Paul Toboni.
The Seattle Mariners need more offense. Many projected them to run away with the AL West, and that just has not happened. The pitching has shown up for the most part, but the real issues have come on offense. The biggest shock has of course been Cal Raleigh, who was in the midst of an 0-38 streak at the plate before singling on Tuesday and is hitting .166. Raleigh should be able to eventually figure it out, but there are other holes throughout the Mariners’ lineup, especially in the middle of the infield.
The Mariners could capitalize on 22-year-old Cole Young’s unexpected start and move him, along with some other pitching prospects, to Washington for Abrams. Abrams is on his way to a career-year at the plate with nine home runs and a .921 OPS and would immediately slot in at the top of the Mariners’ lineup. Defensively, he could shift over to second base long-term to make room for the recently-extended Colt Emerson at shortstop, which may be a more natural fit for him anyway.
3. Athletics receive: RHP Clay Holmes, New York Mets receive: OF Henry Bote (A’s No. 5 prospect per MLB Pipeline) and 3B/1B Tommy White (A’s No. 9)
Clay Holmes has far out-performed the three-year, $38 million contract he signed with the New York Mets last offseason while transitioning to a starting role. This season especially, he has a 1.86 ERA through eight starts and is likely to exercise his opt-out this offseason if he keeps pitching this way. If Holmes signals to the Mets that he is going to opt-out, then the responsible thing for them to do would be to send him off and try and get some value back.
The Athletics are in first place in the AL West, and if they are still in that position in July, then they will need to trade for a starting pitcher if they want to make any sort of noise in the postseason. Half a season of Holmes should not be too expensive, and the A’s have enough prospect depth with Jacob Wilson, Tyler Soderstrom, Lawrence Butler and Brent Rooker all signed long-term where they are able to make these sorts of win-now trades without mortgaging their future.
The Mets need more young position player depth to support their young starters, Nolan McLean and Jonah Tong, and the A’s can provide that. Rookie Carson Benge has had a disappointing start to his Major League career, Bo Bichette does not necessarily look like the answer for the Mets at third base and Marcus Semien is showing his age at second. This would be a rare move that the A’s would be makign for the present, and would give them some positive momentum ahead of their eventual move to Las Vegas.
4. San Diego Padres receive: LHP Tarik Skubal, Detroit Tigers receive: RHP Bradgley Rodriguez, C Ethan Salas (MLB No. 52, Padres No. 1 prospect per MLB Pipeline) and LHP Kash Mayfeld (Padres No. 4)
San Diego Padres general manager A.J. Preller is known for taking huge swings at the trade deadline. No one expected him to acquire guys like Juan Soto or Mason Miller. With the Padres currently in first place in the NL West, a ½ game above the Los Angeles Dodgers, why not go all-in on this season and get arguably the best pitcher in baseball, Tarik Skubal, to round out their depleted starting rotation?
It could take less than initially expected to trade for Skubal because of the surgery he just underwent to remove a loose body from his left elbow, but because of the new procedure used by Dr. Neal ElAttrache that superagent Scott Boras coined the “Skubal Scope,” he could be back pitching for the Detroit Tigers by early June. Having any type of surgery complicates things, especially in a contract year, and it could give Preller just enough of a window to grab Skubal and load up for the postseason.
Even though the Padres, or any other team trading for Skubal would only be getting him for a few months, the price for him would still be steep. Catching prospect Ethan Salas has been lighting it up in the minor leagues and Bradgley Rodriguez is one of the best young relievers in baseball and could step into the closer role for the Tigers going forward. The reality for the Tigers is that if they do not believe they can sign Skubal, then they must trade him. With all of their other injuries and Framber Valdez’s struggles, it does not look like the Tigers are contenders this year, making the potential decision to trade Skubal more palatable.